diff --git a/app/models/sale.rb b/app/models/sale.rb
index 0c537f78..49ef027c 100644
--- a/app/models/sale.rb
+++ b/app/models/sale.rb
@@ -963,7 +963,7 @@ def self.get_by_shift_items(shift_sale_range, shift, from, to, status,type,accou
       product        = product.where("sales.shift_sale_id IN (?) and sale_status='completed'",shift.to_a)
       discount_query = Sale.where("sales.shift_sale_id in (?) and sale_status= 'completed' ", shift.to_a).sum(:total_discount)
       change_amount  = Sale.where("sales.shift_sale_id in (?) and sale_status= 'completed' ", shift.to_a).sum(:amount_changed)
-      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
+      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.empty? ? '""' : payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='cash') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as cash_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='creditnote') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as credit_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='foc') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as foc_amount")
@@ -986,7 +986,7 @@ def self.get_by_shift_items(shift_sale_range, shift, from, to, status,type,accou
       product        = product.where("sales.shift_sale_id IN (?) and sale_status='completed'",shift_sale_range.to_a)
       discount_query = Sale.where("sales.shift_sale_id IN (?) and sale_status ='completed'", shift_sale_range.to_a).sum(:total_discount)
       change_amount  = Sale.where("sales.shift_sale_id IN (?) and sale_status ='completed'", shift_sale_range.to_a).sum(:amount_changed)
-      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
+      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.empty? ? '""' : payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='cash') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as cash_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='creditnote') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as credit_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='foc') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as foc_amount")
@@ -1010,7 +1010,7 @@ def self.get_by_shift_items(shift_sale_range, shift, from, to, status,type,accou
 
       discount_query = Sale.where("sales.receipt_date between ? and ? and sale_status ='completed'", from,to).sum(:total_discount)
       change_amount  = Sale.where("sales.receipt_date between ? and ? and sale_status ='completed'", from,to).sum(:amount_changed)
-      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
+      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.empty? ? '""' : payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='cash') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as cash_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='creditnote') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as credit_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='foc') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as foc_amount")
@@ -1069,7 +1069,7 @@ def self.get_staff_meal_items(shift_sale_range, shift, from, to, status, account
       product        = product.where("sales.shift_sale_id IN (?) and sale_status='completed'",shift.to_a)
       discount_query = Sale.where("sales.shift_sale_id in (?) and sale_status= 'completed' ", shift.to_a).sum(:total_discount)
       change_amount  = Sale.where("sales.shift_sale_id in (?) and sale_status= 'completed' ", shift.to_a).sum(:amount_changed)
-      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
+      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.empty? ? '""' : payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='cash') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as cash_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='creditnote') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as credit_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='foc') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as foc_amount")
@@ -1092,7 +1092,7 @@ def self.get_staff_meal_items(shift_sale_range, shift, from, to, status, account
       product        = product.where("sales.shift_sale_id IN (?) and sale_status='completed'",shift_sale_range.to_a)
       discount_query = Sale.where("sales.shift_sale_id IN (?) and sale_status ='completed'", shift_sale_range.to_a).sum(:total_discount)
       change_amount  = Sale.where("sales.shift_sale_id IN (?) and sale_status ='completed'", shift_sale_range.to_a).sum(:amount_changed)
-      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
+      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.empty? ? '""' : payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='cash') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as cash_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='creditnote') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as credit_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='foc') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as foc_amount")
@@ -1116,7 +1116,7 @@ def self.get_staff_meal_items(shift_sale_range, shift, from, to, status, account
 
       discount_query = Sale.where("sales.receipt_date between ? and ? and sale_status ='completed'", from,to).sum(:total_discount)
       change_amount  = Sale.where("sales.receipt_date between ? and ? and sale_status ='completed'", from,to).sum(:amount_changed)
-      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
+      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.empty? ? '""' : payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='cash') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as cash_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='creditnote') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as credit_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='foc') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as foc_amount")
@@ -1505,7 +1505,7 @@ end
     query = employee_sale(shift, from, to)
     .joins("LEFT JOIN (#{payments_for_credits}) payments_for_credits ON payments_for_credits.sale_id = sales.sale_id")
     .select("SUM(sale_payments.payment_amount) - CASE WHEN sale_payments.payment_method = 'creditnote' THEN IFNULL(SUM(payments_for_credits.payment_amount), 0) ELSE ABS(SUM(CASE WHEN sale_payments.outstanding_amount < 0 THEN sale_payments.outstanding_amount ELSE 0 END)) END AS payment_amount,
-    CASE WHEN sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') }) THEN 'card'
+    CASE WHEN sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.empty? ? '""' : payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') }) THEN 'card'
 		ELSE sale_payments.payment_method END AS payment_method, employees.name AS e_name")
   end
 
@@ -1531,7 +1531,7 @@ end
   def self.total_card_sale(current_user=nil,from=nil,to=nil)
     payment_methods = SalePayment.where.not(payment_method: ['cash', 'creditnote', 'foc']).distinct.pluck(:payment_method)
     query = Sale.joins("JOIN sale_payments sp ON sp.sale_id = sales.sale_id")
-                .where("sales.sale_status = 'completed' and (sp.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') }))")
+                .where("sales.sale_status = 'completed' and (sp.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.empty? ? '""' : payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') }))")
 
     if (!from.nil? && !to.nil?)
       query = query.receipt_date_between(from, to)
@@ -2038,7 +2038,7 @@ def self.get_by_hourly_items(shift_sale_range, shift, from, to, status,type,acco
       product        = product.where("sales.shift_sale_id IN (?) and sale_status='completed'",shift.to_a)
       discount_query = Sale.where("sales.shift_sale_id in (?) and sale_status= 'completed' ", shift.to_a).sum(:total_discount)
       change_amount  = Sale.where("sales.shift_sale_id in (?) and sale_status= 'completed' ", shift.to_a).sum(:amount_changed)
-      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
+      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.empty? ? '""' : payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='cash') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as cash_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='creditnote') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as credit_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='foc') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as foc_amount")
@@ -2061,7 +2061,7 @@ def self.get_by_hourly_items(shift_sale_range, shift, from, to, status,type,acco
       product        = product.where("sales.shift_sale_id IN (?) and sale_status='completed'",shift_sale_range.to_a)
       discount_query = Sale.where("sales.shift_sale_id IN (?) and sale_status ='completed'", shift_sale_range.to_a).sum(:total_discount)
       change_amount  = Sale.where("sales.shift_sale_id IN (?) and sale_status ='completed'", shift_sale_range.to_a).sum(:amount_changed)
-      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
+      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.empty? ? '""' : payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='cash') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as cash_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='creditnote') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as credit_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='foc') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as foc_amount")
@@ -2085,7 +2085,7 @@ def self.get_by_hourly_items(shift_sale_range, shift, from, to, status,type,acco
 
       discount_query = Sale.where("sales.receipt_date between ? and ? and sale_status ='completed'", from,to).sum(:total_discount)
       change_amount  = Sale.where("sales.receipt_date between ? and ? and sale_status ='completed'", from,to).sum(:amount_changed)
-      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
+      sale_cash      = Sale.select("SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.empty? ? '""' : payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as card_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='cash') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as cash_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='creditnote') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as credit_amount,
                                     SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method='foc') then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as foc_amount")
@@ -2247,7 +2247,7 @@ def self.get_daily_sale_data(transaction_date)
 def self.get_check_sale_data(transaction_date)
   payment_methods = SalePayment.where.not(payment_method: ['cash', 'creditnote', 'foc']).distinct.pluck(:payment_method)
   sale_receivables_subquery = "SELECT sale_payments.sale_id,
-      SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as credit_card_sales,
+      SUM(case when (sale_payments.payment_method IN (#{payment_methods.empty? ? '""' : payment_methods.map{ |pm| "\"#{pm}\"" }.join(', ') })) then (sale_payments.payment_amount) else 0 end) as credit_card_sales,
       CASE WHEN sale_payments.payment_method = 'giftvoucher' THEN SUM(sale_payments.payment_amount) ELSE SUM(0) END as voucher_sales
       FROM sale_payments
       GROUP BY sale_payments.sale_id, sale_payments.payment_method"