diff --git a/app/models/sale.rb b/app/models/sale.rb
index e2d1aff4..05442b1e 100644
--- a/app/models/sale.rb
+++ b/app/models/sale.rb
@@ -1587,7 +1587,7 @@ end
     outstanding_query = "SELECT CASE WHEN SUM(sale_payments.outstanding_amount) < 0 THEN SUM(sale_payments.outstanding_amount) ELSE 0 END 
                           FROM sale_payments
                           JOIN sale_audits ON SUBSTRING_INDEX(sale_audits.remark,'||',1)=sale_payments.sale_payment_id
-                          JOIN sales ON sale_audits.sale_id = sales.sale_id
+                          JOIN sales ON sale_payments.sale_id = sales.sale_id
                           WHERE sale_payments.outstanding_amount LIKE '%-%' AND sales.sale_status='completed'"
     
     if (!from.nil? && !to.nil?) && (from != "" && to!="")
@@ -1603,7 +1603,7 @@ end
     sub_query = "SELECT (CASE WHEN SUM(sale_payments.payment_amount) > 0 THEN SUM(sale_payments.payment_amount) + (#{outstanding_query}) ELSE 0 END)
                 FROM sale_payments
                 INNER JOIN sale_audits ON SUBSTRING_INDEX(sale_audits.remark,'||',1)=sale_payments.sale_payment_id
-                INNER JOIN sales ON sale_audits.sale_id = sales.sale_id
+                INNER JOIN sales ON sale_payments.sale_id = sales.sale_id
                 WHERE sales.sale_status='completed'"
 
     if (!from.nil? && !to.nil?) && (from != "" && to!="")
@@ -1758,7 +1758,7 @@ end
     outstanding_query = "SELECT CASE WHEN SUM(sale_payments.outstanding_amount) < 0 THEN SUM(sale_payments.outstanding_amount) ELSE 0 END 
                           FROM sale_payments
                           JOIN sale_audits ON SUBSTRING_INDEX(sale_audits.remark,'||',1)=sale_payments.sale_payment_id
-                          JOIN sales ON sale_audits.sale_id = sales.sale_id
+                          JOIN sales ON sale_payments.sale_id = sales.sale_id
                           WHERE sale_payments.outstanding_amount LIKE '%-%' AND sales.sale_status='completed'"
     
     if (!from.nil? && !to.nil?) && (from != "" && to!="")
@@ -1773,7 +1773,7 @@ end
 
     sub_query = SalePayment.select("(CASE WHEN SUM(sale_payments.payment_amount) > 0 THEN SUM(sale_payments.payment_amount) + (#{outstanding_query}) ELSE 0 END) as total_credit_payment")
                           .joins(" JOIN sale_audits ON SUBSTRING_INDEX(sale_audits.remark,'||',1)=sale_payments.sale_payment_id")
-                          .joins(" JOIN sales ON sale_audits.sale_id = sales.sale_id")
+                          .joins(" JOIN sales ON sale_payments.sale_id = sales.sale_id")
                           .where("sales.sale_status='completed'")
 
     if (!from.nil? && !to.nil?) && (from != "" && to!="")
@@ -1965,7 +1965,7 @@ end
     outstanding_query = "SELECT CASE WHEN SUM(sale_payments.outstanding_amount) < 0 THEN SUM(sale_payments.outstanding_amount) ELSE 0 END 
                           FROM sale_payments
                           JOIN sale_audits ON SUBSTRING_INDEX(sale_audits.remark,'||',1)=sale_payments.sale_payment_id
-                          JOIN sales ON sale_audits.sale_id = sales.sale_id
+                          JOIN sales ON sale_payments.sale_id = sales.sale_id
                           WHERE sale_payments.outstanding_amount LIKE '%-%' AND sales.sale_status='completed'"
     
     if (!from.nil? && !to.nil?) && (from != "" && to!="")
@@ -1981,7 +1981,7 @@ end
     sub_query = "SELECT (CASE WHEN SUM(sale_payments.payment_amount) > 0 THEN SUM(sale_payments.payment_amount) + (#{outstanding_query}) ELSE 0 END)
                 FROM sale_payments
                 INNER JOIN sale_audits ON SUBSTRING_INDEX(sale_audits.remark,'||',1)=sale_payments.sale_payment_id
-                INNER JOIN sales ON sale_audits.sale_id = sales.sale_id
+                INNER JOIN sales ON sale_payments.sale_id = sales.sale_id
                 WHERE sales.sale_status='completed'"
 
     if (!from.nil? && !to.nil?) && (from != "" && to!="")